WHY did Sturgeon resign? We still do not know the answer.
But in Sturgeon’s case, things were not straightforward.
The chattering classes said she called it a day after the trans rapist row. But calling it quits for that reason makes no sense since the storm had already passed on that one. So, why resign?
Is it really the case that she was worn down by the media furore surrounding her Gender Recognition Reform self-identification provisions? Or was it simply exhaustion from her prolonged, ensconced leadership?
Sturgeon did not throw in the towel because some journalists wrote negative stories about her policies. Only the week before, she insisted there was “plenty left in the tank”.
To get to the real reason, you simply need to apply the catchphrase from “All the President’s Men: “follow the money”.
There were two investigations of fraud ongoing in Scotland that were uncomfortable for Sturgeon and the party she led.
Operation Branchform:
A Police investigation which started by following up allegations of possible fundraising fraud by the Scottish National Party Executive
The investigation was launched after seven official complaints were registered in July 2021. The issue was whether or not approximately £666,953 raised for a Scottish independence campaign was in part improperly spent by the SNP on other activities.
The SNP denied all allegations, and many questions remain unanswered, including about a large loan to the SNP from Murrell that recently came to light.
According to sources close to the fraud investigation, the allegations “had substance”, confirming reports that some officers close to the investigation believed criminality may have occurred and wished to question people under caution.
But the Scottish prosecution service, the Crown Office, echoed only the views of senior SNP figures.
The Times reported that Crown Office officials “were inclined to share the view of senior SNP figures who argued all spending by the party ultimately supported its overall aim of independence.”
Adding to the concern were The Times revelations that the Crown Office had attempted to change the wording around the investigation into the SNP’s finances, making the case more interesting.
The reporting also outlined allegations that the prosecution service lobbied for changes so the wording reflected a “fact-finding” exercise, not a formal investigation.
It is fascinating that the prosecution service was more concerned about sparing the ruling SNP poor media coverage than ensuring there would be no whiff of interference by the Crown in the investigation process.
But the curious case of the Crown Office’s antics as Operation Branchform unfolded is compounded by the fact that the public was not provided with clarity.
Discussions between Scotland’s prosecution service and police force around investigations must remain secret. Individuals are not permitted to know. That would not be in the public interest, apparently.
Late in the investigation, the fraud probe belatedly confirmed that they had also been asked to look at a loan of £107,620 made in June 2021 by Peter Murrell, the SNP’s chief executive and husband to Sturgeon.
It was an “extraordinary coincidence” that Murrell’s loan was revealed only a day after the referendum appeal had been the subject of discussions. And there is a point, especially given the loan was notified very late to the Electoral Commission.
But for the public, it was all questions and no answers from Sturgeon or her husband. When the BBC’s Glenn Campbell probed Sturgeon, who had announced her intention to step down from the leadership, she refused to comment about whether or not she expected to be interviewed by the Police:
Glenn Campbell: “Just one factual point. Have you been, or do you expect, to be interviewed by the police who are looking into your party’s finances?”
Nicola Sturgeon: “I’m not going to discuss an ongoing police investigation. I wouldn’t do that on any issue, and I’m not going to do it now.”
The refusal to comment on whether or not the Police interviewed her isn’t the only area where Sturgeon demonstrated a lawyerly caution. When The Herald’s Tom Gordon pressed her on the loan issue directly, Sturgeon claimed not to recall when she first learned of the loan. She also added a curious line about “what he does with his resources is a matter for him”. This is quite a line given we’re talking about a £107,000 loan from her husband (and party chief executive) to the political party she has led for eight years.
Eventually Sturgeon will have to answer questions with greater specificity, if not to journalists, then certainly to Police investigators. What she knew and when she knew it in relation to the Murrell loan to the SNP should surely become part of ‘Operation Branchform’s ’ ongoing fraud investigation.
Officers involved in Branchform sought direction for some time concerning whether to interview senior SNP figures as suspects or as witnesses. The Crown Office insisted on delaying a decision on how to proceed. This is despite the investigation already running for 18 months for allegations that first emerged more than three years prior.
Now that Sturgeon has resigned, it is to be hoped the prosecution service will reach decisions more promptly
The fraud squad probe is not yet at an end, despite the curious Crown Office delay and Sturgeon’s determination to avoid answering journalist questions. With sources close to the investigation saying the fundraising fraud allegations “may have substance” despite the Crown Office slow-walking decisions, Branchform isn’t something we can ignore. Sturgeon previously said her resignation was not a result of “short-term pressures” such as the gender recognition row or which jail to house a trans rapist in, which raises the prospect of another, as yet unknown, more serious factor.
Summary of an article in Think Scotland. written by Dean M Thomson
